Willow904 wrote:Rebecca wrote:Willow904 wrote:
Both David Lammy and Seema Malhotra have resisted "getting on with it and accepting the inevitable", so that's not true. Both have spoken to my feelings in a way Jeremy Corbyn can't, because he has wanted this for a long time. I think there may be a generation gap here. I've been in the EU my whole adult life. Jeremy Corbyn will never be able to connect to me over this issue. I'm frankly not too impressed with being told I have no choice but to have Corbyn because no one else will do anything different. Even politician's with very similar views will make lots of tiny choices that are different that can add up to quite different outcomes.
Of course you have a choice,and have had a choice.
September 2015,labour leadership election.You had a choice.If you didn't vote for Corbyn that's sad for you but you do know he won by a very large margin indeed.
Referendum,you had a choice how to vote.Very sadly for the country,there was a majority vote for leave.
The PLP are using a bucketful of foul means to get rid of Jeremy Corbyn,so sucks to anyone who had a choice and voted for him.
They should have another leadership election and win by fair means if they can,something you could also vote how you choose to.
Seems to me from your posts that you want more than a choice,you want YOUR choice.
That is not democracy.
No, democracy is this. If Labour doesn't offer me what I want and need from a political party, I will leave and join another party. This is true of all of us and we comment here, on a political forum, to express when we approve (I really liked Ed, though I always understood that he didn't really appeal to quite a lot of Labour voters) and we express when we disapprove. I'm just explaining why I can't, personally, support Jeremy Corbyn any longer. There are concrete logical reasons, but mostly there are lot of emotional, incoherent reasons. I have gone over these. I understand that there are a lot of people in the Labour party who are going to stand by Jeremy Corbyn to the bitter end and they are right to do so, if that's how they feel. I'm not trying to change any minds, I'm trying to give you an insight into how not everyone in Labour feels the same and why the intransigence on both sides will pull the party apart.
Yes it is going to pull the party apart, and thats disastrous, but Labour will likely survive.
For those that leave the party (As I did during the warmonger years) it is always a soul wrenching decision, espescially when the civil war in labour is mirrored in your family as it was in mine when the SDP went their own merry way.
Regardless of pro or anti corbyn, this whole shabby coup attempt is a deriliction of duty to the nation, when we do face our greatest crisis sincce the war, and are more divided than in 350 years as a nation. It is that, more than anything else, which disqualifies the plotters in my eyes from any legitamacy. But that is compounded by their abject cowardice and frightening incompetence in actually unseating a man that they are unable by the rules to unseat, added to their utter contempt for the membership, both by refusing to accept last years mandate and refusing to allow the members a decision. Then we have their open and barefaced lies to the British public that have been quickly exposed, the childish petulant behaviour of Jess Phillips when caght lying about McDonneel and the rally last night, the audacity of an elected official claiming he knows how someone voted in a secret ballot - one of the principles of our democracy I might add - It really does give me the measure of those alighned against him in the PLP.
Of the 28 SDP defectors, I think 2 retained their seats at the 83 election.
Elections are cruel, there are always bitterly dissapointed losers in them, but its that or dictatorship.