PorFavor wrote:Well, Hilary Benn is a great hit with the Conservatives.
Well he will be because he came out with the same stuff all previous 'for' speakers have said
Daesh are bad
We have to do something
France asked us
and then backed up by a load of hopeful thinking and trust in the word of The Liar
I come back to a point I made a couple of days ago. There are two justifications for attacking them in Syria and the airstrikes have to have a place in achieving said objective
Make it less likely there is a Daesh attack on UK interests
I find this highly unlikely...in fact it is pretty certain that the risk is that it makes it more likely than less. The likelihood is that any attacks will not be planned in Syria but by radicalised locals. In this Daesh are like Al-Qaeda - they sponsor and help train but the planning is carried out independently
No place for air strikes in reducing this threat
Lead to Military Victory over Daesh
This can be anything from full defeat to rendering irrelevant. I cannot see how this will happen in Syria as it is now...far too many players and far too few active ground troops committed to beating them. I think it is the crux of the argument today...and by far the weakest point in Cameron's shite sell - the ground troops in Syria are mainly fighting the Assad Government apart from the Kurds who are fighting Daesh but are being killed by our 'allies'.....I have seen no real indication that the rebel forces in Syria are that interested in the militants...Assad is the main focus
Again air strikes play not part in the achieving of this objective unless there is a massive ground operation at the same time
As has bee rightly pointed out by a few speakers today the main focus point at the moment should be the Turkish and Saudi Governments and forcing them to close off any supply routes to Daesh, and in the Turkish case to stop killing our only foot soldiers in the area and also to stop provoking the Russians
So, Benn made a rhetorically okay speech but his arguments were as flawed as all the others made in favour.....
In the end we are going to war because we were asked to and they are bad people....seems that is really it