AngryAsWell wrote:
Think of those who would/will "throw their toys" as just like the LibDems who left the party because it was taken over by people who they felt betrayed the principals of the party when they entered the coalition. Cooper is a Labour MP who was voted for by her constituency because they believed in what she stood for. How can she serve in a cabinet who's leaders policies she no longer believes in? To do so would be totally hypocritical. Nothing to do with arrogance at all.
Those of us who have been in the party a long, long time fought the fight in the 80's and have no wish to do so again. To see the same thing happening all over again is - frankly - heart-breaking. I have paid full membership to the Labour party, and contributed to local and national campaign funds, for more years than I care to remember, now my party is being whisked away from me for £3, yet I'm expected to just suck it up and go along the wishes of 3 quid voters and call it "democratic".
I can no more support Corbyn than true Liberal Democrats could support Clegg.
Michael Foot filled halls and rallies as well.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/po ... 15290.html" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Thank you, AAW.
NB - I do not include you in the few posters who irritate; I appreciate your points, but I think I don't agree with them all. Some, sure.
I think many of us who left a lifelong interest in all things Liberal after Clegg's behaviour were particularly annoyed with him because he had campaigned on a left-of-centre ticket; it seemed, to me anyway, that it was a step way too far to go into full coalition with the Tories. They will have to do something pretty dramatic to get me back...
Labour is a much bigger party and it has always had some dichotomy between its' left and right. I thought Miliband did a fantastic job keeping the party as united as possible, and I think he would have made a good PM and statesman. Maybe he will yet.
He faced an unprecedented situation in Scotland; I still think that without that and the Tory press, a lethal combination, he could have won and he really wasn't that far off. He wasn't helped by some of his own MPs - like Danzcuk - briefing against him.
What interests me is how Corbyn's ideas are, IMHO, nowhere near as "left" as they are made out to be - and I also think that one of the reasons why people are listening to him is because he isn't an Identikit politician.
I also think it is wrong - and, yes, arrogant - for any MP to suggest that if called to serve their party (and their country) in opposition thy will take their skills and experience to the back benches. It looks like pique.
Hopefully, when the vote is done we'll know where we are; if the full breakdown of the votes is published, we'll find out whether it was the fully paid-up members who made the result decisive. Until then, we don't know if it'll be the "£3 supporters" who swung it.
I think you and I are agreed that we'd like to see a strong opposition - we're just not agreed on how to get there.